Compare On-Call Platforms: Rootly vs PagerDuty vs Opsgenie

When your systems go down, every second counts. An outage can mean lost revenue, frustrated customers, and a stressed-out engineering team. That's where on-call platforms come in. These tools are essential for modern tech companies, ensuring the right person is alerted immediately when something breaks so they can fix it fast.

This article will help you compare oncall platforms by looking at three major players in the incident management space: Rootly, PagerDuty, and Opsgenie. We'll explore what each one offers to help you find the best fit for your team. PagerDuty is the long-established leader, Opsgenie is the tool owned by Atlassian, and Rootly is the modern, all-in-one solution designed for today’s complex systems.

At a Glance: Rootly vs. PagerDuty vs. Opsgenie Comparison

Here’s a quick overview to help you see how these platforms stack up against each other.

Feature

Rootly

PagerDuty

Opsgenie

Core Functionality

All-in-one Incident Management & On-Call

Primarily On-Call Alerting

Primarily On-Call Alerting

Pricing Model

Unified pricing

Tiered, per-user

Tiered, per-user

Key Strength

Automation & Workflow

Extensive Integrations

User-friendliness

Future Outlook

Actively Developed

Established

End-of-Life

Deep Dive: PagerDuty

PagerDuty is one of the most well-known names in the digital operations and incident response market. For years, it has built a reputation for its powerful alerting capabilities and a massive library of integrations that connect with almost any tool. It holds a high user satisfaction rating of 97% and a strong overall score of 8.9 [3].

PagerDuty Pros & Cons

Pros:

• Reliable Alerting: PagerDuty is known for its robust and dependable alerting system, ensuring that on-call engineers get notified without fail.
• Extensive Integrations: It offers a vast ecosystem of integrations, with 49 different connections to monitoring, communication, and other tools [1].
• Advanced Features: The platform includes advanced functionality like event intelligence, which is designed to meet the needs of large, complex enterprises.

Cons:

• High Cost: PagerDuty is often cited as being expensive, which is a major reason why organizations look for PagerDuty alternatives [7].
• Complex Interface: New users sometimes find the platform's interface to be complex and difficult to navigate.
• Siloed Functionality: While PagerDuty has incident management features, they are often treated as a separate product or add-on, leading to additional costs and a less integrated experience.

PagerDuty Pricing

PagerDuty uses a tiered pricing model that starts with a very limited free plan and scales up to costly enterprise packages. The plans are typically priced per user, per month, which can become very expensive as your team grows [2]. Teams often find themselves paying for multiple tools to cover the full incident lifecycle, increasing the total cost of ownership.

Deep Dive: Opsgenie

Opsgenie is Atlassian's on-call and alerting tool, which gained popularity for its user-friendly design and competitive pricing. However, there's a critical factor to consider: Atlassian has announced the end-of-life for Opsgenie. This means the product will no longer be updated or supported, making it a risky choice for any team looking for a long-term solution. For those needing to move off the platform, Rootly provides a straightforward migration path. You can learn more about how Rootly helps you transition away from Opsgenie here.

Opsgenie Pros & Cons

Pros:

• Affordable and Simple (Historically): Opsgenie was known for being more affordable and easier to get started with compared to PagerDuty [5].
• Atlassian Ecosystem Integration: It integrates well with other Atlassian products like Jira and Confluence.

Cons:

• End-of-Life: This is the most significant drawback. The product is being sunset by Atlassian, which means no future development, no security patches, and an eventual requirement to migrate to a new platform.
• Limited Features: Even before its end-of-life announcement, Opsgenie had fewer advanced features and integrations compared to PagerDuty.
• A Risky Choice: Choosing a tool that is no longer being developed is not a sustainable strategy for effective incident management, which is crucial for minimizing the financial impact of service disruptions [4].

Opsgenie Pricing

Opsgenie's pricing was once a key advantage, offering a simpler and more affordable structure than PagerDuty. However, given that the product is now at its end-of-life, its pricing model is no longer relevant. Any team using it will need to budget for a migration to a new platform soon.

Deep Dive: Rootly

Rootly is a modern, all-in-one incident management platform that includes powerful on-call scheduling and alerting with Rootly On-Call. Unlike tools that focus only on alerting, Rootly's approach is to centralize the entire incident lifecycle—from the initial alert to the final retrospective—all within a single, cohesive platform. This makes it one of the strongest PagerDuty alternatives and the ideal migration destination for teams leaving Opsgenie [8].

Rootly Pros & Cons

Pros:

• Unified Platform: Rootly brings together incident response, on-call management, status pages, retrospectives, and analytics. This eliminates tool sprawl—the need to patch together and pay for multiple different services.
• Powerful Automation: Rootly's workflow engine is a key differentiator. It automates dozens of manual tasks, such as paging the correct on-call engineer, creating a Slack channel, starting a video call, and keeping stakeholders updated.
• Cost-Effective: By combining the functionality of several tools into one, Rootly offers a much better total cost of ownership. You pay one price for a complete solution rather than separate fees for alerting, incident management, and status pages.
• Wholesale Replacement: Rootly isn't just an add-on; it can serve as a complete replacement for both PagerDuty and Opsgenie, offering a more modern and integrated workflow.

Cons:

• Comprehensive by Design: For a team looking for a very simple alerting tool and nothing else, Rootly's comprehensive feature set might seem like more than they need at first glance. However, as teams mature, having these capabilities integrated becomes a significant long-term advantage.

Rootly as a PagerDuty and Opsgenie Alternative

Rootly directly addresses the pain points of older, legacy tools.

For teams currently using PagerDuty, Rootly offers a more complete and centralized solution. Instead of just integrating with an alerting tool, Rootly can replace it entirely, streamlining your processes and costs. To understand how this works, you can explore the details of the PagerDuty and Rootly integration, which for many teams evolves into a full migration.

For teams searching for Opsgenie alternatives, Rootly is the clear choice. It provides a modern, actively developed platform that goes far beyond what Opsgenie offered, ensuring your team is supported for years to come. The platform is designed to make the switch seamless, providing a clear path for teams moving on from Atlassian's deprecated tool.

Conclusion: Making the Right Choice for Your Team

Choosing the right on-call platform is critical for maintaining service reliability and keeping your team effective. Let's recap the options:

• PagerDuty: A powerful, feature-rich platform for alerting, but it can be expensive and complex, often requiring other tools to manage the full incident lifecycle.
• Opsgenie: A tool with no future. Its end-of-life status makes it an unwise and unsustainable choice for any organization.
• Rootly: The modern, all-in-one solution. It streamlines the entire incident process, automates repetitive work, and provides a cost-effective, unified platform for both on-call alerting and incident management.

For teams looking for a future-proof, efficient, and integrated solution that will grow with them, Rootly is the superior choice. It empowers engineers to resolve incidents faster while reducing the manual toil that leads to burnout.

Ready to see how a modern, unified platform can transform your incident management? Book a demo with Rootly today.

‍