Jira Service Manager vs. Rootly

You want incident management with Rootly's all-in-one on-call and incident response platformnot project management and an expensive page.

PagerDuty logo
JSM
PagerDuty
Rootly logo
Rootly
Rootly

Top JSM Challenges Solved By Rootly

PagerDuty logo
JSM
Rootly logo
Rootly
PagerDuty logo

JSM slows response with portal-first workflows.

Rootly logo

Rootly is a top JSM alternative that goes beyond paging to offer a complete end-to-end solution for managing the entire incident. In addition to alerting, Rootly provides tools for automating communication, running retrospectives, and ensuring seamless collaboration across teams.

PagerDuty logo

Our teams do not collaborate in JSM to respond to incidents, we use tools like Slack or Teams.

Rootly logo

With Rootly, you can seamlessly collaborate in Slack or Teams without having to switch between different platforms.

PagerDuty logo

JSM needs per-project rules to turn alerts into incidents.

Rootly logo

Rootly natively promotes alerts, spins up the room/bridge, pages responders, and syncs systems automatically.

PagerDuty logo

JSM puts major incidents and post-incident reviews behind Premium/Enterprise.

Rootly logo

Rootly includes retrospectives and AI in the standard incident flow with one-click retro exports.

PagerDuty logo

The UI feels dated, unintuitive, is hard to configure, and feels like it was built 15 years ago.

Rootly logo

Rootly’s UI is guided, intuitive, and easy to navigate. It is designed with user experience in mind, ensuring that even non-technical users can easily manage on-call schedules and incident workflows. 

PagerDuty logo

Configuring and updating on-call schedules and overrides is difficult and doesn't feel human-centric. JSM’s on-call reports lag and miss readiness checks too.

Rootly logo

Rootly is designed to adapt on-call scheduling to how your teams actually work. You can easily configure and update schedules based on your team’s specific needs, like adjusting shifts for time off with vacation-aware scheduling, and hassle-free overrides. Rootly also offers built-in gap detection and on-call readiness reports, features unique to our platform.

PagerDuty logo

Innovation and feature development has remained stagnant. We lack many table stake features.

Rootly logo

Rootly is continuously evolving to meet the needs of modern incident response teams. We stay on the bleeding edge of innovation and make sure your team has all the tools it needs to stay ahead of the incidents.

PagerDuty logo

JSM migrations from Opsgenie introduce rework and breaking changes.

Rootly logo

Rootly automates migration of schedules, policies, configs, and users so you modernize IR—not just port it.

PagerDuty logo

JSM’s virtual agent runs in only one chat at a time.

Rootly logo

Rootly works natively across both Slack and Microsoft Teams for consistent incident response and in multiple chats.

PagerDuty logo

Frustrated by the consistent upsells and price increases that no longer fit our budget.

Rootly logo

We offer simple and straightforward pricing, with no per-alerts, surprise bills, or silly upsells. And did we mention, it’s half the cost of JSM?

End-to-End Incident
Management With Rootly

Rootly is an end-to-end incident management platform that powers the entire incident response lifecycle, while JSM is primarily a ticketing tool with basic incident management features available at an extra cost.

Stunning Mobile App

Stunning Mobile App

A mobile experience so sleek, you won’t mind getting paged.

Native Shadow Rotations

Native Shadow Rotations

Make onboarding seamless with easy-to-schedule shadow rotations.

On-Call Pay Calculator

On-Call Pay Calculator

Simplify on-call compensation and generate reports in just a few clicks.

Synced Slack User Groups

Synced Slack User Groups

On-call schedules are synced to Slack user groups, ensuring that whoever is currently on call is automatically reflected within Slack.

Schedule Gap Detection

Schedule Gap Detection

Rootly’s gap detection automatically identifies coverage gaps and assigns them to the Schedule Owner, notifying them to take action.

Seamless Overrides

Seamless Overrides

Whether you need coverage for a dentist appointment or an entire shift, Rootly makes it simple to request an override with just a click.

Cycle-Based Round Robin

Cycle-Based Round Robin

Rootly’s round robin feature automatically rotates on-call responsibilities, ensuring that no single team member is overwhelmed.

Slack Native

Slack Native

With Rootly, you can see who is currently on-call, upcoming shifts, and manually page responders without logging into web. 

Simple Escalation Policies

Simple Escalation Policies

Rootly’s easy-to-configure escalation policies ensure that the right people are notified when incidents exceed predefined thresholds.

Feature Comparison

Incident Response
Rootly
JSM
On-Call, Response, and Learning all under one roof, not just paging
Status pages
💰
Incident timeline tracking
Incident roles and tasks
Automated workflows
AI-powered response copilot, metrics, related incidents
Customizable retrospectives and metrics
💰
Scheduling
Rootly
JSM
Sync with Slack user groups automatically(@team-infra) with on-call schedules
Native shadow rotation support without duplicate schedule workarounds
Native cycle-based round-robin scheduling on top of alert-based
Automated gap detection
Native timezone support in schedule editor
Modern drag-and-drop schedule builder
AI-powered schedule creation using natural language (beta)
Auto-create secondary schedules that sync with primary ones (beta)
Overrides
Rootly
JSM
Configure basic overrides
Request coverage via self-serve override requests
Bulk overrides across multiple schedules
Partial overrides for specific timeframe
Schedule owners to cover any gaps and true 24/7 gapless  schedules
Best-practice templates like “Follow the Sun” built-in
Escalation Policies (EP)
Rootly
JSM
Build EPs that consist of teams, individuals, services, and/or Slack
Intuitive and guided UI for managing EPs, designed for complex needs
Organize EP by usage state to clean up stale policies
Page an EP directly without needing to attach a service
Users
Rootly
JSM
Beautiful streamlined UI designed for anyone to use - not just engineers
View connected notification methods for all users in one place
Configure user notification preferences (high vs. low)
On-call pay calculator
Paging
Rootly
JSM
Ability to page teams natively without modelling everything as a service
iOS and Android mobile app
Ability to bypass “do not disturb” device settings
Manually page responders without creating an incident
Automated handoffs between on-call shifts
Live call routing
Alerts
Rootly
JSM
Alert grouping and routing
Unlimited # of SMS and phone alerts
Multiple phone and SMS providers as backup, not just Twilio
Not every alert is created as an incident
Integrations
Rootly
JSM
All popular alert sources (like Datadog, Splunk, etc.) and generic webhook
Built to be Slack native
See who is currently on-call, upcoming shifts, all alertsManually page responders without logging in to web
Bi-directional ticket syncing with Jira, Zendesk, etc.
Reliability, Security, & Enterprise-Readiness
Rootly
JSM
Heartbeat monitoring alert sources (ensure all sources are active and working)
Granular RBAC settings (feature-by-feature control)
Terraform and API
SSO / SCIM groups support
Straightforward and cost effective pricing. Predictable with no surprise increases.

What our customers say

Joanne H.Joanne H.

Joanne H.

Engineering Director, Reliability Platform, Canva

We no longer need to have engineers maintaining an in-house solution - we could never catch up to the number of features Rootly was shipping, and the ongoing operational load was significant.

Scott K.Scott K.

Scott K.

Engineering Manager, Replit

The single most impressive thing about Rootly is how fast they ship. At times we’ve reported a bug or feature request only to have it fixed live within 10-15 minutes.

 Chris I. Chris I.

Chris I.

Director of Engineering, Wealthsimple

We started focusing more on dedicated incident management solutions, like Rootly, FireHydrant, Incident.io, and a few more. In the end, Rootly was the option that best met our needs while providing the flexibility we needed as a high growth company.

Enoch L.Enoch L.

Enoch L.

Site Reliability Engineer, Bolt

Working with Rootly feels like a partnership; as we continued to use their tool and found more use cases, our feature requests quickly found their way into (or, luckily for us, were already in) their backlog.

 Verified User Verified User

Verified User

Computer & Network Security

Rootly stood out as having the most number of integrations that are actually useful. It is simple, easy to use, yet highly customizable to your organization. We use it every time there is an active incident - in fact, we have made Rootly the starting point of our organization’s incident response process.

Colin F.Colin F.

Colin F.

Incident & Problem Manager, Webflow

It provides us with data where there was none, allowed us to standardize our process, and has increased the automations that let our incident response team focus on responding and not on managing a third party product.

Joanne H.Joanne H.

Joanne H.

Engineering Director, Reliability Platform, Canva

We no longer need to have engineers maintaining an in-house solution - we could never catch up to the number of features Rootly was shipping, and the ongoing operational load was significant.

Scott K.Scott K.

Scott K.

Engineering Manager, Replit

The single most impressive thing about Rootly is how fast they ship. At times we’ve reported a bug or feature request only to have it fixed live within 10-15 minutes.

 Chris I. Chris I.

Chris I.

Director of Engineering, Wealthsimple

We started focusing more on dedicated incident management solutions, like Rootly, FireHydrant, Incident.io, and a few more. In the end, Rootly was the option that best met our needs while providing the flexibility we needed as a high growth company.

Enoch L.Enoch L.

Enoch L.

Site Reliability Engineer, Bolt

Working with Rootly feels like a partnership; as we continued to use their tool and found more use cases, our feature requests quickly found their way into (or, luckily for us, were already in) their backlog.

 Verified User Verified User

Verified User

Computer & Network Security

Rootly stood out as having the most number of integrations that are actually useful. It is simple, easy to use, yet highly customizable to your organization. We use it every time there is an active incident - in fact, we have made Rootly the starting point of our organization’s incident response process.

Colin F.Colin F.

Colin F.

Incident & Problem Manager, Webflow

It provides us with data where there was none, allowed us to standardize our process, and has increased the automations that let our incident response team focus on responding and not on managing a third party product.

Mark F.Mark F.

Mark F.

Director of Engineering, Faire

Rootly adds simple automation to incident management without large process changes

 Cory A. Cory A.

Cory A.

Engineer, Flickr & Smugmug

Rootly has been a great partner to work with from the beginning. Rootly has always listened to our feedback.

Matthew M.Matthew M.

Matthew M.

Senior Site Reliability Engineer, Upstart

With Rootly, incident spin-up time has been reduced from minutes to seconds and it covers over 90% of our needs. Overall, Rootly is the best tool currently available in the market.

Karl K.Karl K.

Karl K.

Incident Engineer, Rush Street Interactive

Rootly has very clear and easy to use guidelines, helpful descriptions and that enables people with little to no previous experience in Incident Management to jump straight into creating their first incident!

Shane B.Shane B.

Shane B.

Site Reliability Engineer, Roller Digital

Rootly allows us to focus on the issue at hand when we have an incident by removing a lot of the laborious tasks required when resolving an incident.

Verified UserVerified User

Verified User

Computer & Network Security

Their customer facing team are all friendly, easy going, and highly responsive. I would pick Rootly for their people alone.

Mark F.Mark F.

Mark F.

Director of Engineering, Faire

Rootly adds simple automation to incident management without large process changes

 Cory A. Cory A.

Cory A.

Engineer, Flickr & Smugmug

Rootly has been a great partner to work with from the beginning. Rootly has always listened to our feedback.

Matthew M.Matthew M.

Matthew M.

Senior Site Reliability Engineer, Upstart

With Rootly, incident spin-up time has been reduced from minutes to seconds and it covers over 90% of our needs. Overall, Rootly is the best tool currently available in the market.

Karl K.Karl K.

Karl K.

Incident Engineer, Rush Street Interactive

Rootly has very clear and easy to use guidelines, helpful descriptions and that enables people with little to no previous experience in Incident Management to jump straight into creating their first incident!

Shane B.Shane B.

Shane B.

Site Reliability Engineer, Roller Digital

Rootly allows us to focus on the issue at hand when we have an incident by removing a lot of the laborious tasks required when resolving an incident.

Verified UserVerified User

Verified User

Computer & Network Security

Their customer facing team are all friendly, easy going, and highly responsive. I would pick Rootly for their people alone.

Are you an
early-stage company?

Best-in-class incident response should be accessible for everyone. All the features at a fraction of the cost.

ELIGIBILITY

< 100

employees

< $50m

raised

< 5 years

in business

Companies backed by xare also eligible for additional discounts.

By submitting this form, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use and agree to sharing your information with Rootly and Google.

Curious, but still have a few questions?

Does Rootly offer the same on-call scheduling and paging features as JSM?

Rootly’s On-Call solution incorporates all the core on-call and paging features you’re familiar with from JSM, making it simple for teams to adopt. We’ve deliberately kept the learning curve minimal, so teams can get up and running quickly.

Beyond that, Rootly surpasses JSM with advanced features like native shadow rotations, on-call calculator, and seamless overrides.

Plus, Rootly’s intuitive, modern interface ensures any team member can manage schedules and escalations with ease.

Can Rootly do more than just paging?

Absolutely! Rootly goes beyond paging to offer a complete end-to-end solution for managing the entire incident. In addition to alerting, Rootly helps your team quickly investigate potential incidents before escalating, assemble the right responders in seconds, automate communications and task tracking, and generate comprehensive incident retrospectives. By consolidating these capabilities in one platform, Rootly eliminates the need for multiple tools, offering greater value and efficiency at a more affordable price point.

Is Rootly as reliable as JSM?

Yes, reliability is our #1 feature. Rootly is the only alerting solution built on top of a 99.99% uptime commitment, ensuring you won’t miss a single alert.

How does Rootly compare to JSM in terms of cost?

Rootly offers a more transparent pricing structure with no hidden upsells or surprise price hikes. Our pricing is designed to scale with your business, ensuring you only pay for what you need, while still providing powerful incident management tools— at a fraction of the cost of JSM.

How easy is it to switch from JSM to Rootly?

We have an automated migration process that pulls over schedules, escalation policies, and user details. A team of experts who are former PagerDuty and Opsgenie employees are dedicated to ensuring this process is seamless. The entire migration process for small teams is a matter of minutes, but for larger organizations can be longer depending on complexity.

Does it integrate with the tools I’m already using?

Absolutely! Rootly integrates with over 100 native tools, including Slack, Jira, Sentry, Confluence, DataDog, making it easy to incorporate the tools you rely on into your incident response process.