.avif)
.png){kind=icon}
.png){kind=icon}
Effective incident management is non-negotiable in modern DevOps and Site Reliability Engineering (SRE). Unplanned downtime can cost organizations over $300,000 per hour, making the right tooling essential for maintaining uptime and customer trust [2]. While PagerDuty and Rootly are both prominent site reliability engineering tools, they offer fundamentally different approaches. This article compares both platforms to show why Rootly provides a more comprehensive and efficient solution for DevOps incident management.
Understanding the Players: PagerDuty vs. Rootly
What is PagerDuty?
PagerDuty is a well-established platform known primarily for on-call management and alerting. It excels at notifying the right people when an issue arises. However, its core focus remains on the initial alert rather than the entire incident lifecycle.
This alert-centric model can lead to challenges. PagerDuty's pricing has become increasingly complex, with many essential features locked behind expensive tiers or add-on packages [8]. This complexity and focus on notifications alone have led many teams to seek alternatives that offer a more integrated experience and better value [6].
What is Rootly?
Rootly is a modern, comprehensive incident management platform built for collaboration and automation. Instead of just handling alerts, Rootly manages the entire incident lifecycle, from detection and response to resolution and post-incident learning.
The platform's core philosophy is to use intelligent automation to streamline processes, which reduces the cognitive load on engineering teams during stressful outages. This allows responders to focus on fixing the problem rather than getting bogged down by manual administrative tasks. You can explore a detailed overview of Rootly's incident management features to understand how it supports teams at every stage.
Head-to-Head Feature Comparison
The differences between Rootly's lifecycle approach and PagerDuty's alert-first model become clear when comparing their features side-by-side.
Feature
Rootly
PagerDuty
Core Focus
End-to-end incident management, collaboration, and automation.
On-call scheduling and alert notification.
Incident Workflows
Powerful, native automation for the entire response process.
Automation primarily focused on alert routing and escalations.
On-Call Management
Natively includes on-call scheduling and alerting.
Core strength; robust and mature feature set.
Retrospectives
Built-in, automated post-incident analysis and learning.
Basic capabilities; often requires other tools for deep analysis.
Integrations
Deep, native integrations (e.g., Slack) for a central command center.
Broad integrations, but often as alert sources, not collaboration hubs.
Pricing Model
Transparent, all-in-one pricing.
Complex tiered model with costly add-ons. [7]
Analytics & Reporting
Comprehensive metrics on incidents, MTTR, and team performance.
Focused on alerting and on-call metrics.
Core Philosophy: Full Lifecycle vs. Alert-First
Rootly's Approach
Rootly is designed as a central command center for incidents. Its collaboration-first design, especially its deep integration with Slack, brings all incident-related activities into a single, unified workspace [3]. By focusing on automating the entire response process—from declaring an incident to generating a retrospective—Rootly ensures consistency and efficiency from start to finish.
PagerDuty's Approach
PagerDuty’s strength lies in its robust on-call scheduling and alerting engine, which has helped it capture a significant market share in IT alerting [1]. However, its architecture is fundamentally alert-driven. While it has added incident management features over time, the experience can feel disjointed, often requiring teams to switch between PagerDuty for alerts and other tools like Slack for communication and Confluence for documentation.
Automation and Workflows
Rootly
Rootly's powerful workflow engine is a key differentiator. It automates dozens of manual tasks, such as creating incident channels, inviting responders, assigning roles, and updating status pages. These automated workflows can even use alerts from PagerDuty as triggers, immediately initiating a structured and automated response process the moment an issue is detected.
PagerDuty
PagerDuty's automation is primarily focused on the alerting and escalation process. While effective for notifications, it doesn't extend to the full range of response activities. Automating the entire incident lifecycle with PagerDuty often requires purchasing add-ons, relying on other tools, or building custom scripts, whereas this functionality is native to Rootly.
Better Together or a Full Replacement?
A common question for teams is whether to use Rootly alongside PagerDuty or as a complete replacement. Rootly offers the flexibility to do both.
Option 1: Supercharge PagerDuty with Rootly
You can integrate Rootly seamlessly with your existing PagerDuty setup to create a powerful, end-to-end solution. The PagerDuty - Rootly integration allows you to:
- Ingest PagerDuty alerts to automatically declare incidents in Rootly.
- Automate paging and invite on-call personnel from PagerDuty into Rootly-managed incident channels.
- Maintain a two-way sync between Rootly incidents and PagerDuty services to keep statuses aligned.
Rootly's Smart Defaults feature further simplifies this process, making it easy to configure the integration and start automating your response in minutes.
Option 2: Replace PagerDuty with Rootly On-Call
For teams looking to consolidate their toolchain and reduce costs, Rootly can serve as a wholesale replacement for PagerDuty. With the introduction of Rootly On-Call, the platform provides a complete solution for on-call scheduling and alerting, in addition to its robust incident response and retrospective capabilities.
This allows organizations to manage their entire incident management stack—from who gets paged to how the incident is resolved and what is learned—within a single platform. This unified approach simplifies tooling, reduces subscription costs, and creates a more cohesive user experience. As noted in the documentation, many users find that Rootly On-Call is a complete alternative, asking, "Should I keep paying for PagerDuty or does Rootly replace it?" The answer is yes, Rootly can fully replace it.
Conclusion: The Modern Choice for Resilient Systems
While PagerDuty remains a capable tool for alerting, Rootly offers a superior solution for modern DevOps and SRE teams focused on building resilient systems. Its advantages are clear:
- A comprehensive, single-platform approach to the entire incident lifecycle.
- Powerful, native automation that reduces Mean Time to Resolution (MTTR) and eliminates manual toil.
- A collaboration-first design that meets teams where they already work.
- Flexible deployment that can either enhance PagerDuty or replace it entirely.
For teams looking to move beyond simple alerting and adopt a more streamlined and effective approach to DevOps incident management, Rootly is the forward-thinking choice [2].
Ready to see how Rootly can transform your incident management? Book a demo today.