Why Rootly Beats PagerDuty: Automation Edge for 2026

In today's digital landscape, system reliability is paramount. Incident management has evolved from a simple break-fix process into a critical business function. For years, PagerDuty has been a cornerstone of this process, excelling at on-call management and alerting. But as we look toward 2026, the game has changed. Simply notifying teams is no longer enough. This is where Rootly enters the picture. As a modern, comprehensive incident management platform, Rootly offers a significant automation advantage. This article will compare both platforms, explaining why Rootly's automation-first approach makes it the superior choice and the leading PagerDuty alternative for forward-thinking organizations.

The Traditional Approach: A Look at PagerDuty's Model

PagerDuty has long been the go-to solution for aggregating alerts from monitoring systems and ensuring the right person is notified when something breaks. Its strength lies in its reliable on-call scheduling and notification engine, which has served countless teams well.

However, as systems grow in complexity and incident stakes get higher, it's clear that the initial alert is just the beginning of the story. The real challenge—and where most delays and manual work occur—is in the coordination and resolution process. In fast-paced, modern DevOps environments, the limitations of an alert-centric model are becoming more apparent.

PagerDuty's Limitations in a Modern DevOps World

While PagerDuty is effective at what it does, its architecture reveals constraints when pushed to automate complex, end-to-end incident response.

• Workflow and Action Constraints: PagerDuty's Workflow Automation, formerly Catalytic, has documented system limits that can hinder scalable automation. For example, teams are capped at 10 action starts per second and a maximum of 1,000 fields per workflow instance [4]. These constraints can become bottlenecks for organizations trying to orchestrate sophisticated, multi-tool response plays.
• Scalability Challenges: Performance can suffer as an organization's service catalog grows. A known issue highlights that when PagerDuty service counts exceed 800, users experience timeouts when trying to manage those services via integrations like Statuspage [2]. This suggests potential scalability problems for large, complex environments. Other integrations also note the need to be mindful of PagerDuty's API rate limits under heavy use [1].
• Manual Coordination Overhead: Beyond the initial page, many critical response steps in PagerDuty remain manual. Creating dedicated Slack channels, spinning up a conference bridge, updating internal stakeholders, creating Jira tickets, and compiling a retrospective all require manual effort. This toil not only slows down resolution but also increases the cognitive load on engineers during already stressful situations.

The Automation-First Future: Rootly's Decisive Advantage

Rootly is an enterprise-grade incident management platform designed from the ground up to automate the entire incident lifecycle, not just the initial alert. Trusted by industry leaders like Cisco and NVIDIA [7], Rootly integrates seamlessly with your existing tools—including Slack, Jira, and even PagerDuty—to create a single, unified command center for incident response.

How Rootly's Automation Engine Delivers Superior Value

Rootly transforms incident response from a reactive, manual process into a streamlined, automated, and consistent practice.

• The Power of Incident Workflows: The backbone of Rootly's automation is its powerful incident workflows. These allow you to codify your entire response process, ensuring best practices are followed every time. Workflows can be triggered by dozens of events—like an incident being created, its severity being updated, or a service being impacted—to orchestrate actions across your entire tech stack. For example, a single workflow can automatically:
  • Create a dedicated Slack channel and invite the right responders.
  • Page the on-call team via PagerDuty or Rootly On-Call.
  • Create a corresponding Jira ticket.
  • Post automated status updates to stakeholders.
• AI-Powered Assistance (GenAI): Rootly leverages Generative AI to eliminate even more manual work. Its AI capabilities are designed to augment your team, not just provide data. Key features include automatic incident summarization for quick context, proactive troubleshooting suggestions based on past incidents, and AI-assisted retrospective generation to capture learnings effortlessly [6].
• Seamless, Actionable Integrations: Many tools offer simple data connectors that only pull information [3], [5]. Rootly’s integrations are built for action. With a vast library of integrations, Rootly allows your workflows to control other tools, creating a truly automated ecosystem [8]. The deep integration with PagerDuty is a perfect example, allowing Rootly to enhance PagerDuty's alerting with comprehensive response automation.

Rootly + PagerDuty: Better Together or Full Replacement?

For teams already invested in PagerDuty, the question of how to adopt Rootly is common. You have two excellent options.

Option 1: Supercharge PagerDuty with Rootly
You can use Rootly as your central incident management hub while continuing to use PagerDuty for on-call scheduling and paging. After a simple installation process, an alert might still originate from PagerDuty, but it can trigger a Rootly workflow that handles the rest of the incident response. You can even design Rootly workflows that automatically page the correct on-call team in PagerDuty based on the incident's service or severity, enriching PagerDuty's core functionality with intelligent automation.

Option 2: Rootly as a Wholesale Replacement
For teams seeking to consolidate their toolchain for greater efficiency and cost savings, Rootly can now serve as a complete PagerDuty replacement. With the release of Rootly On-Call, you can manage on-call schedules, escalations, and notifications directly within the same platform that automates your incident response. This creates a single, unified solution for the entire incident lifecycle, from detection to resolution and learning. An overview of the integration often answers common questions about making the switch.

Feature-by-Feature: Rootly vs. PagerDuty for 2026

Here's a direct comparison of how the two platforms stack up for the demands of 2026:

Feature

PagerDuty

Rootly

Core Focus

On-call Management & Alerting

End-to-End Incident Management

Automation

Basic, limited workflows

Highly customizable, trigger-based workflows across all tools

AI Capabilities

Limited or none

Integrated GenAI for summaries, troubleshooting, and retrospectives

Collaboration

Alert-centric communication

Slack-native command center for unified collaboration

Retrospectives

Manual process

Automated generation with timeline, metrics, and action items

Scalability

Known performance limits with high service counts

Enterprise-grade, scalable architecture built for growth

Integrations

Data connectors for visibility

Actionable integrations for cross-tool automation

Conclusion: Why the Automation Edge Makes Rootly the Clear Winner

The future of incident management isn't about more alerts; it's about smarter, faster, and more consistent resolution. While PagerDuty is an effective alerting tool, it was not built for the comprehensive automation that modern engineering teams require to manage complex systems and reduce cognitive load.

Rootly was built from the ground up to automate the entire incident lifecycle, from detection and response to learning and prevention. Its powerful workflow engine, AI-driven assistance, and actionable integrations provide a decisive advantage. For organizations looking to build more resilient systems and empower their teams in 2026 and beyond, Rootly's automation edge makes it the definitive PagerDuty alternative.

See Rootly's automation in action. Schedule a demo today.

‍