Rootly Postmortems: Automation vs. Manual Docs

Postmortems are a critical practice for any engineering team serious about improving system reliability. They transform incidents from mere failures into valuable learning opportunities. However, the traditional process of creating postmortems with manual documentation is often a painful, time-consuming chore that teams dread. This is where automation changes the game. By moving away from static documents, platforms like Rootly transform postmortems into a streamlined, valuable, and integrated workflow that drives real improvement.

The Problem with Manual Postmortem Documentation

When teams rely on tools like Google Docs or Confluence for manual postmortem creation, they consistently run into the same roadblocks. This manual approach is fraught with challenges that undermine the very purpose of the postmortem.

• Time-Consuming: Engineers can spend hours after an incident manually hunting down and copy-pasting chat logs, metrics from monitoring tools, and screenshots to piece together a timeline. This is time that could be spent on high-value engineering work.
• Inconsistent: Without a rigid, enforced structure, postmortems often vary wildly in quality, format, and depth. This inconsistency makes it nearly impossible to analyze trends or compare incidents over time.
• Prone to Blame: A manual process that relies on individual recollection can easily devolve into finger-pointing. The focus shifts from systemic issues to individual mistakes, creating a toxic culture of blame that discourages transparency.
• Action Items Get Lost: Action items buried in a static document are disconnected from engineering workflows. They are difficult to assign, track, and follow up on, meaning crucial fixes and improvements often fall through the cracks and are never implemented.

What’s the difference between Rootly postmortems and manual documentation?

The difference between a postmortem generated in Rootly and one created in a manual document is the difference between a dynamic, actionable workflow and a static, forgotten record. Rootly's automation provides a clear advantage at every step of the process, saving your team valuable time and ensuring every incident leads to meaningful improvement.

Feature

Manual Documentation (e.g., Google Docs)

Rootly Automation

Data Gathering

Hours of manual copy-pasting from Slack, Jira, Datadog, and other tools.

The incident timeline is automatically populated with every message, command, and alert.

Template Consistency

Relies on engineers finding and correctly using the right template, if one even exists.

Enforces standardized, easily configurable templates for every incident, ensuring quality.

Action Item Tracking

A static checklist in a document, disconnected from engineering backlogs.

Creates integrated tasks with assignees, due dates, and bidirectional sync with Jira, Asana, and more.

Collaboration & Sharing

Requires manually sharing document links and managing view/edit permissions.

A centralized platform where reports can be automatically shared to Slack and exported to Confluence.

Metrics & Insights

Requires manually digging through past documents to find trends.

Automatically generates key reliability metrics like MTTR, incident frequency, and recurring causes.

How does Rootly help create blameless postmortems?

Creating a blameless culture is essential for effective incident response, and Rootly is designed to foster it. By shifting the focus from people to process, Rootly helps your team answer "what happened?" instead of "who did it wrong?"

• Data-Driven Narrative: Rootly automatically builds a complete, timestamped timeline of events based on immutable data from your integrated tools. This factual record removes subjectivity and speculation, grounding the entire discussion in objective reality.
• Structured Templates: Rootly’s postmortem templates guide teams through a structured analysis. By prompting questions about contributing factors, system weaknesses, and detection time, they steer the conversation toward systemic improvements rather than individual errors.
• Focus on Process: When the timeline is built automatically, it becomes much easier to analyze the incident response process itself. Teams can spot communication gaps, slow manual steps, or toolchain deficiencies that contributed to the incident's impact, leading to a more resilient system.

How does Rootly automate action item tracking from postmortems?

One of the most significant failures of manual postmortems is the inability to track action items to completion. Rootly solves this by deeply integrating action item tracking into your incident management workflow.

You can create action items (known as Tasks and Follow-ups) directly from the incident timeline in Slack or the Rootly web UI [2]. As your team discusses the incident, any identified improvement can be instantly captured. The process is simple:

1. An action is identified during the postmortem review.
2. It’s created in Rootly with a clear title.
3. The task is assigned to an owner or team.
4. A priority and due date are set to ensure accountability.

Rootly can even be configured to automatically send reminders to assignees about upcoming or overdue action items, eliminating the need for manual follow-up. Most importantly, Rootly features native, bidirectional integrations with project management tools like Jira, Asana, and Linear. This ensures that action items appear directly in your engineering team's existing backlogs, seamlessly connecting incident learnings to your development lifecycle.

How can Rootly share postmortems with cross-functional teams easily?

Incidents impact more than just the engineering team. Customer support, sales, and leadership all need visibility. With manual docs, sharing is a messy process of sending links and managing permissions. Rootly makes sharing simple, transparent, and automatic.

• Centralized Platform: Rootly acts as the single source of truth for all incident information. Stakeholders with the right permissions can access a clean, consistent view of all past and present postmortems.
• Automated Exports: Stop wasting time formatting reports. Rootly can automatically generate a polished postmortem report and push it to collaboration hubs like Confluence or Notion, ensuring your organization's knowledge base is always up to date.
• Slack Integration: Keep everyone in the loop without adding noise. Postmortem summaries and links can be automatically shared in relevant public or private Slack channels, such as #engineering-leadership or #customer-support-updates.
• Further Automation: For custom workflows, you can connect Rootly to other services. Platforms like Nekton allow users to build powerful automations, such as creating a Salesforce case or a Freshservice ticket whenever a postmortem is published [3].

Beyond the Postmortem: Automating the Remediation Workflow

A successful postmortem often uncovers underlying security vulnerabilities or misconfigurations that need to be addressed. These findings add to the application security (AppSec) backlog, which can quickly become a bottleneck that slows down development [4].

Just as Rootly automates the post-incident learning process, modern tools can automate the remediation workflow that follows. Instead of leaving engineers to manually research and apply fixes, automated vulnerability remediation (AVR) platforms can deliver solutions directly. This process often involves using "surgical patches" that target a specific vulnerability without requiring a full container rebuild, minimizing disruption and risk [1]. By connecting automated postmortems with automated remediation, you create a powerful, end-to-end cycle of continuous improvement.

Conclusion: Ditch the Docs, Embrace Automation

The contrast is clear. Manual documentation produces a static, time-consuming record that is difficult to act on. Rootly delivers a dynamic, actionable, and deeply integrated workflow that turns every incident into a driver for improvement.

By embracing automation, you can save valuable engineering time, improve system reliability, and foster a culture of blameless, continuous learning. Stop letting action items get lost in forgotten documents. It's time to transform your incident management lifecycle.

Ready to see how automated postmortems can revolutionize your incident response? Book a demo with Rootly today.

‍