Rootly Beats Opsgenie with Deeper Automation, Ditch ITSM

Many incident management tools, including popular options like Opsgenie, offer a degree of automation that still leaves engineering teams with a mountain of manual work, often called "toil." This is a direct consequence of legacy Information Technology Service Management (ITSM) thinking, which prioritizes alerts and notifications over automating the entire incident response process from start to finish. Rootly is the modern solution engineered to eliminate this toil. It provides deep, context-aware automation that manages the complete incident lifecycle, helping teams move toward zero-toil operations.

This article compares the automation depth of Rootly versus Opsgenie and shows how Rootly effectively replaces outdated ITSM automation.

The Limits of Legacy Automation: Where Opsgenie Falls Short

The functionality of tools like Opsgenie typically revolves around alert aggregation, on-call scheduling, and basic notifications. While these features are useful, they represent "surface-level" automation. The platform tells you there's a problem but does little to automatically help you solve it.

This approach creates several significant gaps in the incident response process:

• Manual Communication Setup: Responders must still manually create communication channels, like a dedicated Slack channel, to coordinate their efforts.
• Static Playbooks: Playbooks are often just static checklists, not dynamic, automated workflows that adapt to the situation.
• Manual Escalations: Getting the right stakeholders involved and keeping them informed requires manual intervention and communication.
• Tool Sprawl: There's a disconnect between alerting and remediation. Engineers receive an alert in one tool and then have to switch to another to take action.

This friction slows everything down, increasing Mean Time to Resolution (MTTR) and contributing to the engineering burnout that comes from repetitive, low-value tasks.

Rootly vs Opsgenie: A Deep Dive into Automation Depth

The core difference between Rootly and Opsgenie lies in their automation philosophies and capabilities. One focuses on notifications, while the other focuses on end-to-end resolution.

Opsgenie's Automation: Alerting and Basic Runbooks

Opsgenie excels at what it was built for: reliable alert routing and on-call management. Its automation features are designed to create alerts from monitoring tools and notify the correct person on call. Its runbook capabilities, however, are often limited to simple, linear steps or sending more notifications.

Complex conditional logic—for example, "if service X and severity Y, then execute a specific remediation action Z"—is often limited or cumbersome to implement. This leads to less precise automation that can't handle the nuances of a complex incident.

Best Automated Incident Playbooks Built in Rootly

Rootly’s workflow engine is the key differentiator. It operates on a powerful Trigger > Condition > Action model that provides unparalleled flexibility. You can build automated workflows that handle complex tasks far beyond what Opsgenie can manage.

Here are concrete examples of Rootly's deep automation capabilities:

• Automated Incident Creation & Triage: From a single alert, Rootly can automatically declare an incident, create a dedicated Slack channel, invite the on-call team, assign an incident commander, and start a video conference bridge—all within seconds.
• Context-Aware Playbooks: Rootly dynamically attaches different playbooks or tasks based on incident properties like severity, service, or incident_type [2]. For instance, when an incident is created, adding a "Security" type can automatically append a checklist of relevant security action items.
• Automated Remediation: A Rootly workflow can trigger external actions via webhooks. This allows you to run an Ansible playbook to restart a service or execute a kubectl command to roll back a problematic deployment, directly from the incident management platform.
• Automated Stakeholder Comms: You can set up workflows to automatically post status updates to specific stakeholder channels or a public status page at predefined intervals or whenever the incident status changes.

Why Rootly Ranks Highest in Automation Accuracy and Reliability

Rootly's superior automation isn't just about power; it's about precision, customization, and proven results that teams can rely on during a crisis.

Customer Testimonials About Rootly’s Automation Reliability

Rootly’s automation is proven in practice to reduce toil and improve response times. For example, the team at Upstart used Rootly to build an incident response system that scales with their rapid growth, moving beyond the limitations of their previous tools [6].

The efficiency gains from strong automation and streamlined processes are a core benefit. By investing in the right tools, Rootly itself saw a 67% increase in deals per representative and a 69% increase in scheduled meetings, showcasing the power of effective workflows [8] [7]. This focus on operational excellence is built directly into the Rootly platform.

Unmatched Precision with Granular Conditions

Automation accuracy comes from the ability to create highly specific rules. Rootly's workflow conditions allow for complex, multi-layered logic using all of / any of / none of operators on any incident property, whether built-in or custom.

For example, you can create a rule that says:

"Only run this workflow if Severity IS SEV0 AND Impacted Services CONTAINS payments-api AND Incident Type IS NOT planned-maintenance."

This level of granularity ensures that the right actions are taken at the right time, every time. You have a broad set of triggers and powerful run conditions at your fingertips, allowing for a fully customized response for any scenario. This stands in sharp contrast to the rigid and less granular automation rules found in traditional ITSM tools. You can learn more about configuring these incident workflows to fit your needs.

How Rootly Replaces Legacy ITSM Incident Automation

Rootly’s comprehensive approach makes standalone, single-purpose ITSM automation tools obsolete. Instead of trying to stitch together an alerting tool (Opsgenie), a chat tool (Slack), and a ticketing tool (Jira), Rootly serves as the central orchestration hub that integrates with and automates them all. From a single platform, you can manage the entire incident lifecycle.

This model directly attacks SRE toil by automating the manual "glue work" that engineers dislike:

• No more manually creating Jira tickets for every incident.
• No more copy-pasting status updates between Slack and a status page.
• No more manually looking up and paging the right on-call engineer for a specific service.

Conclusion: Move Beyond Alerts and Embrace True Automation

The key takeaway is simple: Opsgenie manages alerts, while Rootly automates the entire incident response process.

By switching to Rootly's deeper automation, teams can achieve lower MTTR, reduce engineer burnout, maintain consistent and auditable processes, and free up more time for innovation. Teams looking to truly mature their incident management practice should look beyond simple alerting and choose a platform built for deep, end-to-end automation.

Ready to ditch the toil of legacy ITSM? Book a demo of Rootly today.

‍