Incident Response Automation: Rootly Beats PagerDuty

In modern tech operations, downtime isn't just an inconvenience; it's a major cost. Organizations can lose over $300,000 for every hour of infrastructure failure [2]. This is why incident response automation is critical—it helps engineering teams reduce manual work and resolve outages faster. While PagerDuty is a well-known tool for on-call management and alerting, it's only one piece of the puzzle.

Rootly, on the other hand, is a more comprehensive incident response automation software designed to manage the entire incident lifecycle from start to finish. This article compares both platforms and shows why Rootly provides a superior, end-to-end solution for modern incident management.

Understanding the Landscape of Automated Incident Response Tools

Incident response automation is the use of software to streamline the tasks involved in detecting, managing, and resolving technical incidents. By automating repetitive administrative work, these tools provide significant benefits.

• Drastically reduce Mean Time to Resolution (MTTR): Automation gets the right people involved and provides them with the right information faster.
• Minimize human error: During stressful outages, it's easy to forget steps. Automation ensures processes are followed consistently.
• Enable teams to focus on the fix: Engineers can concentrate on resolving the underlying problem instead of managing communication and administrative tasks.

Effective incident management platforms achieve this through core features like automated workflows, centralized communication hubs, and deep integrations with other tools in the tech stack [2].

PagerDuty: The Standard for On-Call Alerting

PagerDuty is a dominant force in the IT Alerting and Incident Management space, holding a significant market share and ranking as a top tool in the category [1]. Its primary function is to handle on-call scheduling, alerting, and escalations. When a monitoring tool detects an issue, PagerDuty excels at notifying the correct engineers.

However, its core strength lies in alerting, not in comprehensive response automation. While PagerDuty has added features for incident management over time, its platform wasn't originally built to manage the entire incident lifecycle. This leaves gaps in areas like collaborative response, automated task management, and post-incident learning.

Rootly: A Comprehensive Incident Management Platform

Rootly is a purpose-built incident response automation software that goes far beyond simple alerts. It's designed to centralize and automate the entire incident lifecycle, from initial detection all the way through post-incident analysis. As a collaboration-first platform, Rootly focuses on making incident response more productive and less chaotic [3].

While Rootly offers a seamless integration with PagerDuty to enhance its alerting capabilities, it can also function as a complete, standalone incident management solution. Many teams find that Rootly provides a more holistic and powerful alternative, serving as a central hub for all incident-related activities.

Head-to-Head Comparison: Why Rootly Excels

When comparing Rootly and PagerDuty, the differences become clear across several key areas of incident management.

Automation and Workflows

PagerDuty: Its automation capabilities are primarily focused on routing alerts and triggering escalation policies based on incoming events from monitoring systems.

Rootly: Rootly offers a powerful and highly customizable workflow engine that automates tasks throughout an incident. This allows teams to codify their entire response process. Examples of automated actions include:

• Creating a dedicated Slack channel for the incident.
• Automatically inviting the right responders and assigning roles.
• Updating a public status page.
• Generating a post-incident timeline and report.

Features like Smart Defaults provide out-of-the-box automation, making it easy for teams to get started and standardize their response without complex configuration.

Collaboration and Integrations

PagerDuty: The platform integrates with many tools, but these connections are often one-way—ingesting alerts to trigger a notification.

Rootly: Rootly's integrations are deep and bi-directional, creating a true central command center for incidents. Its native, Slack-based approach keeps teams collaborating in the tool they use every day [4]. For example, the Rootly and PagerDuty integration allows for a two-way sync of incident status, importing PagerDuty services, and automatically assembling teams based on who is on call. This enriches PagerDuty's alerts with Rootly's powerful response capabilities.

Post-Incident Learning and Analytics

PagerDuty: Its capabilities for post-incident reviews and analytics are more limited, focusing primarily on alerting metrics.

Rootly: Rootly automatically captures every action, chat message, and timestamp related to an incident. This data is used to generate comprehensive retrospectives and insightful metrics. By using incident properties to categorize incidents, teams can easily analyze trends, identify recurring problems, and pinpoint areas for improvement. This fosters a culture of continuous learning and helps prevent future outages.

The Bigger Picture: The Rise of SOAR Platforms

The move toward comprehensive automation is part of a broader industry trend known as Security Orchestration, Automation, and Response (SOAR). While SOAR is often associated with security, its principles apply directly to reliability engineering and incident response. Leading platforms show where the industry is heading:

• Google Security Operations offers a unified platform with low-code automation playbooks to accelerate response [6].
• Cortex XSOAR centralizes incident data and automates repetitive tasks, claiming to reduce incident response time by up to 90% [7].
• CrowdStrike Falcon Fusion is a no-code SOAR platform that uses AI-ready automation to help teams respond to threats at machine speed [8].

Rootly brings this same powerful, automation-first mindset to the world of reliability and infrastructure incidents.

Conclusion: Choose a Dedicated Platform for True Automation

While PagerDuty is an excellent tool for alerting, it's not a complete automated incident response tool. Its focus remains on notifying the right people, not on managing the entire response process.

For organizations serious about improving reliability, reducing MTTR, and easing the burden on their engineering teams, a dedicated platform is the clear choice. Rootly's key advantages—end-to-end automation, a focus on collaboration, and powerful post-incident capabilities—make it a superior solution. By centralizing the entire incident lifecycle, Rootly empowers teams to move faster, collaborate more effectively, and build more resilient systems. It’s not just an add-on to your alerting tool; it’s a complete incident management platform that can unify your entire response.

Ready to see how a dedicated incident management platform can transform your operations? Book a demo of Rootly today.

‍