Incident Management Software Review: Rootly Beats PagerDuty

In today's fast-paced digital environment, effective incident management is non-negotiable for modern DevOps and Site Reliability Engineering (SRE) teams. The ability to quickly detect, respond to, and resolve service outages is critical for maintaining customer trust and business continuity. For years, PagerDuty has been a dominant player, primarily known for its on-call and alerting capabilities. However, a new generation of comprehensive incident management software is emerging.

Among these, Rootly stands out. It goes beyond simple alerting to manage the entire incident lifecycle, from detection to resolution and learning. This makes Rootly a superior choice for many organizations looking to mature their DevOps incident management processes.

Understanding the Core Players: What is PagerDuty?

PagerDuty is a well-established tool in the IT operations space, recognized for its robust on-call scheduling and alert management features. It has built a strong market position and is ranked as a leader in IT Alerting and Incident Management [1]. Its core function is to ensure the right people are notified when a system fails.

However, despite its popularity, its feature set can be overly complex for some organizations. This complexity, combined with pricing models that can include expensive add-ons, has led many teams to start evaluating PagerDuty alternatives that better align with their specific needs and budget [2].

A Comprehensive Contender: What is Rootly?

Rootly is an end-to-end incident management platform built to help teams resolve incidents faster and, just as importantly, learn from them more effectively. Unlike tools that focus only on alerting, Rootly covers the entire incident lifecycle—from detection and alerting through to response, resolution, and retrospectives.

Rootly's core philosophy is centered on automation to reduce the manual toil that burdens engineers during a crisis. It achieves this through powerful integrations with tools teams already use, such as Slack, Jira, and Zoom [3]. By automating routine tasks, Rootly frees up responders to focus on what matters most: fixing the problem.

Head-to-Head: A Detailed Alert Management Software Comparison

To understand which tool is right for your team, it helps to compare their features directly. This alert management software comparison highlights where each platform shines and how their approaches differ.

Feature Area

PagerDuty

Rootly

On-Call & Alerting

Core strength with robust scheduling and escalations.

Provides a complete on-call scheduling and alerting solution, capable of fully replacing PagerDuty.

Incident Response

Basic, often manual response coordination capabilities.

Core strength with automated workflows for creating channels, assigning roles, and centralizing communication.

Retrospectives

Post-incident analysis is a more manual process.

Automated retrospective generation that pulls data from the incident timeline for accurate, data-driven learning.

Integrations

Solid library of integrations.

Extensive ecosystem of over 70 integrations, acting as a central hub for the entire tech stack.

On-Call Scheduling and Alerting

PagerDuty: This is PagerDuty's bread and butter. It excels at robust on-call scheduling, complex escalation policies, and reliable multi-channel notifications. For many years, it has been the go-to solution for getting alerts to the right engineer.

Rootly: Rootly offers its own powerful solution, Rootly On-Call, which serves as a complete, modern alternative for scheduling and alerting. For teams already invested in PagerDuty, Rootly provides a deep integration that allows you to enhance your existing setup with powerful automation. This flexibility means you can either augment PagerDuty or migrate away from it entirely, all within the Rootly platform.

Incident Response and Coordination

PagerDuty: While PagerDuty does offer features for incident response, they are not as automated or deeply integrated as those in specialized platforms. Coordination often requires engineers to switch between different tools to manage communication and track tasks.

Rootly: This is where Rootly shines. Its powerful workflow engine automates the entire response process. When an incident is declared, Rootly can automatically spin up dedicated channels, invite the correct responders, and assign roles. All events, communications, and actions are captured in a centralized incident timeline, creating a single source of truth without manual effort. Incident management happens seamlessly within Slack, eliminating the need to leave the chat interface.

Retrospectives and Continuous Learning

PagerDuty: Post-incident analysis in PagerDuty is a largely manual process. Teams must gather data from various sources to piece together what happened, which is time-consuming and can lead to inaccurate conclusions.

Rootly: Rootly automates the creation of retrospectives (post-mortems). It pulls data directly from the incident timeline to generate a detailed report, complete with key metrics, a chronological history of events, and participant information. From there, teams can easily assign action items and track their progress. This focus on learning is detailed in Rootly's approach to analytics and retrospectives, helping you analyze metrics like Mean Time to Detect (MTTD) and Mean Time to Resolution (MTTR) to drive continuous improvement.

Integrations and Ecosystem

PagerDuty: PagerDuty has a solid library of integrations, allowing it to connect with many common monitoring and communication tools.

Rootly: Rootly is designed to be the central hub that connects an organization's entire toolchain. It boasts an extensive library of over 70 integrations across categories like alerting, project management, communication, observability, and more [4]. This vast ecosystem ensures a seamless response process where data and actions flow effortlessly between the tools your team relies on every day.

Why DevOps Teams Are Choosing Rootly Over PagerDuty

Modern DevOps teams are increasingly choosing Rootly for their DevOps incident management needs. The reasons are clear:

• Unified Platform: Rootly provides a single pane of glass for the entire incident lifecycle, from the initial alert to the final retrospective. This eliminates the need for context-switching and keeps everyone on the same page.
• Powerful Automation: The workflow engine automates hundreds of manual steps, saving valuable engineering time, reducing the risk of human error, and allowing responders to focus on technical resolution.
• Flexibility: Teams can start by using Rootly to supercharge their existing PagerDuty setup and gradually migrate, or they can adopt Rootly as a complete replacement from day one. This offers a flexible and pragmatic adoption path.
• Cost-Effectiveness: By consolidating tools and automating manual work, Rootly delivers a significant return on investment. Many teams seek alternatives to PagerDuty to find solutions with more transparent and predictable pricing [5].

The Broader Landscape of PagerDuty Alternatives

The market for incident management tools is growing, and Rootly isn't the only one of the PagerDuty alternatives. Other notable players include Zenduty, which focuses on features for fast-growing SRE teams [6], and various open-source options like ElastAlert and Cabot for teams seeking maximum customization [7].

While PagerDuty still benefits from strong brand recognition, this has made it difficult for competitors to gain visibility, even as they innovate [8]. However, comprehensive and modern solutions like Rootly are rapidly gaining ground by offering a fundamentally better approach to managing incidents.

Conclusion: Why Rootly is the Superior Choice for Incident Management

While PagerDuty remains a capable tool for on-call scheduling and alerting, Rootly represents the future of incident management software. It offers a superior, comprehensive platform that addresses the entire incident lifecycle.

Rootly's key advantages—end-to-end management, deep automation, and a strong focus on learning and improvement—make it the clear winner. For teams looking to mature their DevOps practices, reduce manual work, and build more resilient systems, Rootly provides the tools and workflows needed to succeed.

Ready to see how Rootly can transform your incident management? Request a demo of Rootly today and discover a better way to respond to incidents.

‍