DevOps incident management: Rootly vs traditional software

In today's digital-first world, downtime isn't just an inconvenience; it's a direct threat to the bottom line. Unplanned downtime costs Global 2000 companies an estimated $400 billion annually [4]. For many mid-size and large enterprises, the cost for a single hour of downtime now exceeds $300,000 [1]. As systems become more complex, traditional incident management tools are buckling under the pressure.

This fragmented approach creates friction, slows down teams, and inflates costs. This article compares the traditional, disjointed software stack with a modern, integrated platform like Rootly for superior DevOps incident management.

The Shortcomings of Traditional Incident Management Software

The traditional approach to incident management relies on a patchwork of disconnected tools. Alerts fire in one system, communication happens in another, tickets are tracked elsewhere, and post-mortems live in a separate document. This setup creates significant inefficiency and burnout for DevOps and Site Reliability Engineering (SRE) teams.

Tool Sprawl and Context Switching

Engineers are forced to constantly jump between applications—from PagerDuty for alerts, to Slack for communication, to Jira for tickets, and Google Docs for retrospectives. This context switching creates cognitive overload, slows down response times, and increases the risk of human error during a high-stakes incident. The manual effort of copying and pasting information between these systems means critical data and context are inevitably lost.

Manual Toil and Inconsistent Processes

Using traditional tools, engineers are burdened with repetitive, manual tasks (toil). Every time an incident strikes, they must manually create a war room, hunt down and invite the right people, and remember to send out stakeholder updates. Without a centralized system, incident response processes become inconsistent across teams, leading to confusion, poor coordination, and longer outages.

Fragmented Data and Ineffective Learning

When incident data is siloed across different tools, getting a clear picture of performance is nearly impossible. Key metrics like Mean Time to Resolution (MTTR) are difficult to calculate and often inaccurate. This lack of unified data cripples the ability to conduct effective post-incident reviews and learn from failures, making it far more likely that the same incidents will recur.

What’s included in the modern SRE tooling stack?

A modern SRE tooling stack is designed for integration and efficiency, providing a comprehensive toolkit to maintain system reliability. The essential components include:

• Monitoring and Observability: Tools like Datadog and Grafana provide visibility into system health.
• Alerting and On-Call Management: Systems like PagerDuty and Rootly On-Call ensure the right person is notified.
• Incident Response and Management: A central platform like Rootly orchestrates the entire response.
• Communication and Collaboration: Tools like Slack and Microsoft Teams for real-time coordination.
• Retrospectives and Learning: Processes for analyzing incidents and driving improvement.
• Analytics and Reporting: Dashboards to track key reliability metrics.

The trend is to consolidate these functions into a single platform. With 66% of organizations using multiple monitoring tools, the need for a central hub to manage incidents is critical [8]. You can learn more about the 10 SRE Tools the Most Reliable Engineering Teams Actually Use to build a robust toolkit.

Rootly: A Modern, Integrated Approach to Incident Management

Rootly is a comprehensive incident management platform built to eliminate the chaos of traditional software. By centralizing the entire incident lifecycle—from detection to resolution and learning—Rootly empowers your team to resolve issues faster and build more resilient systems. It provides a single pane of glass for understanding how Rootly works.

A Central Command Center with Deep Integrations

Rootly acts as the central command center for your incident response, integrating seamlessly with the tools your team already relies on. The native Slack integration allows responders to manage the entire incident without ever leaving their chat client.

Rootly unifies alerts, communication, runbooks, and documentation into a single, chronological timeline. It also provides a powerful PagerDuty integration to automate paging and assemble the right response team in seconds.

Powerful Automation to Eliminate Toil

Stop wasting engineering time on manual, repetitive tasks. Rootly’s powerful workflow engine automates tedious work so your team can focus on solving the problem. With Rootly, you can automate critical actions like:

• Automatically creating a dedicated Slack channel and inviting the on-call engineer.
• Paging the correct team based on the affected service.
• Posting scheduled reminders and stakeholder updates.
• Creating a retrospective template automatically upon incident resolution.

Consistent Processes and Data-Driven Insights

Rootly helps you standardize best-practice incident response across your organization. Use customizable templates, forms, and required fields to ensure every incident follows a consistent process.

As your team works, Rootly automatically captures hundreds of data points, creating a rich dataset for analysis. Key metrics like MTTR, Mean Time to Detect (MTTD), and incident frequency by service or severity become instantly accessible on real-time dashboards, transforming incident data into actionable insights.

Comparison: Rootly vs. Traditional Incident Management Software

The difference between a modern platform and a collection of traditional tools is stark. See how Rootly streamlines every step of the process.

Feature

Traditional Software

Rootly

Incident Declaration

Manual creation in multiple systems.

Automated or single-command creation from Slack/UI.

Team Mobilization

Manual lookups and invites.

Automated paging via on-call schedules and escalation policies.

Communication

Manual status updates across different channels.

Automated, scheduled updates to Slack and status pages.

Retrospectives

Manual data gathering in separate documents.

Auto-generated retrospectives with a complete timeline and metrics.

Analytics

Fragmented, hard-to-collect data.

Centralized, real-time dashboards and reports.

Why On-Call Engineers Prefer an Integrated Platform

When searching for the best tools for on-call engineers, look for platforms that reduce stress, not add to it. An integrated platform like Rootly is designed to improve the on-call experience by removing friction and providing clear, guided workflows.

Engineers choose Rootly for several key benefits:

• Reduced Cognitive Load: Automation and guided workflows mean engineers don't have to remember every manual step under pressure.
• Faster Response: Incidents are declared and teams are mobilized in seconds, not minutes.
• Elimination of Toil: Engineers are freed from administrative tasks, allowing them to focus on investigation and resolution.
• Clarity and Consistency: Standardized processes and clear roles ensure everyone knows what to do.

Whether you need a complete on-call solution with Rootly On-Call or want to enhance your existing provider like PagerDuty, Rootly provides the flexibility to build the perfect workflow for your team.

Conclusion: Elevate Your DevOps Incident Management with Rootly

Traditional, siloed tools create friction, slow down response, and increase the cost of downtime. A modern, integrated platform is a necessity for any organization serious about reliability. Rootly provides an automated, data-driven solution that streamlines the entire incident lifecycle.

By switching to Rootly, you can achieve faster resolution times, reduce downtime costs, prevent engineer burnout, and foster a world-class culture of reliability.

Ready to see how a modern incident management platform can transform your operations? Book a demo of Rootly today.

‍