Compare On‑Call Platforms: Rootly, Opsgenie, PagerDuty in 2025

Choosing the right on-call management and incident response platform is critical for modern site reliability engineering (SRE) and operations teams. An effective tool can mean the difference between a minor blip and a costly, reputation-damaging outage. For years, the market has been led by major players like PagerDuty and Opsgenie. However, as of November 2025, the landscape is undergoing a significant shift.

Amid these changes, Rootly is emerging as a powerful, comprehensive platform that challenges the status quo. This article provides a detailed comparison of Rootly, PagerDuty, and the now-legacy Opsgenie to help your team select the best solution for today's complex operational challenges.

The Changing Landscape of On-Call and Incident Management

Incident management has evolved far beyond simple alerting. Modern platforms are expected to provide end-to-end support, from detection and response to resolution and learning. A major challenge for on-call engineers is "alert fatigue," where a constant stream of notifications makes it difficult to identify and prioritize critical issues [1]. This necessitates tools that can intelligently filter signals from noise and automate routine response tasks.

The financial stakes are higher than ever. For many organizations, even minutes of downtime can translate into significant revenue loss and customer churn, creating a strong business case for investing in a superior incident management platform [2]. A key market disruption is Atlassian's announcement that Opsgenie is reaching its end-of-life, forcing thousands of teams to find a suitable alternative and accelerating the move toward more modern, integrated solutions.

Head-to-Head Platform Comparison: Rootly vs. PagerDuty vs. Opsgenie

When you compare oncall platforms, it's crucial to look beyond basic alerting and scheduling to the entire incident lifecycle.

Rootly: The Modern Command Center

Rootly is a comprehensive incident management and on-call solution built for the entire incident lifecycle. A key differentiator is its native Slack integration, which allows teams to manage incidents directly within the communication hub they use every day. This creates a centralized command center that streamlines collaboration and reduces context switching.

While Rootly has long been a leader in incident response, its capabilities now extend to full on-call management, making it a complete solution that can replace legacy platforms. By combining alerting, scheduling, and response in one place, Rootly provides a unified experience. It is not just an alerting tool but a complete incident management platform that helps teams through every phase of an incident [4].

Key features include:

• Automated workflows and runbooks
• A robust service catalog
• Retrospectives and post-incident analysis
• Integrated on-call scheduling and escalations
• Powerful, bi-directional integrations with tools like Jira, Datadog, and more

With Rootly, teams can manage everything from the initial alert to the final retrospective without leaving their primary workspace. Teams can even use it alongside PagerDuty during a transition or as a complete replacement.

PagerDuty: The Established Incumbent

PagerDuty has long been a leader in the digital operations management space. Its reputation is built on robust and reliable alerting, extensive integrations, and mature on-call scheduling capabilities. For many years, it has been the default choice for teams needing to ensure critical alerts reach the right person at the right time.

However, many organizations now seek PagerDuty alternatives. A common reason is its pricing model, which often gates essential features like advanced analytics and stakeholder communications behind expensive, enterprise-level plans [8]. While powerful for alerting, its incident response features can feel like an add-on rather than a core, seamlessly integrated part of the platform. This can lead to a disjointed workflow compared to more modern, all-in-one solutions.

Opsgenie: The End of an Era

Opsgenie, part of the Atlassian suite, served as a popular on-call management tool, particularly for teams already invested in products like Jira and Confluence. It offered strong scheduling and alerting features that integrated well within its parent ecosystem.

Unfortunately, Atlassian has announced the end-of-life for Opsgenie. This makes it a non-viable option for any new customers and presents a significant risk for existing users, who must now plan a migration strategy to a supported platform. For these teams, Rootly offers a seamless migration path. You can easily import existing Opsgenie services to ensure a smooth, uninterrupted transition to a more modern and future-proof platform.

Feature and Pricing Breakdown: A Side-by-Side Look

A direct comparison highlights the different philosophies behind each platform. While some platforms excel in specific areas, others aim to provide more holistic value. For a broader look at how different tools stack up, comparison sites can offer detailed feature breakdowns [5].

Feature

Rootly

PagerDuty

Opsgenie (Legacy)

On-Call Management

- Fully-featured on-call scheduling, escalations, and overrides.- Integrated directly with incident response workflows.

- Mature and robust on-call scheduling.- Core strength of the platform.

- Strong on-call scheduling.- Now facing end-of-life.

Incident Response

- Native, end-to-end incident management inside Slack.- Automated workflows (Runbooks).- Centralized command center.

- Add-on incident response features.- Can be less integrated than dedicated solutions.

- Basic incident response capabilities.- Less comprehensive than modern platforms.

Pricing Model

- Transparent, all-in-one pricing designed to scale without punitive tiers.

- Tiered pricing structure.- Key features are often in higher-priced plans [7].

- N/A due to end-of-life.

Integrations

- Deep, bi-directional integrations with tools like Slack, Jira, Datadog, etc.- Import services from both PagerDuty and Opsgenie.

- Extensive integration library.- One of its primary strengths.

- Good integration with the Atlassian suite.

Overall Value

- High value from combining on-call and a full incident management platform.- Reduces tool sprawl and total cost of ownership.

- Can become expensive as teams scale or require more features.

- No future value due to end-of-life.

How to Choose the Right On-Call Platform in 2025

Your choice depends on your team's specific needs, current tooling, and future goals.

For Teams Seeking PagerDuty Alternatives

If your team is using PagerDuty but is frustrated with its complexity, high cost, or siloed approach to incident response, it's time to evaluate alternatives. Rootly stands out as a powerful PagerDuty alternative that offers a more complete, integrated solution. It combines best-in-class incident response with robust on-call management, often at a lower total cost of ownership. You can integrate Rootly with PagerDuty to enhance your response capabilities or use it as a full replacement to consolidate your toolchain.

For Teams Seeking Opsgenie Alternatives

For current Opsgenie users, the need to migrate is urgent. This is an opportunity not just to find a replacement but to upgrade your entire incident management practice. As one of the leading Opsgenie alternatives, Rootly is the ideal choice for this transition. It offers a modern feature set that goes far beyond what Opsgenie provided. More importantly, Rootly provides a dedicated migration path that allows you to import schedules and services, ensuring a smooth and efficient transition with minimal disruption to your on-call teams.

Conclusion: Modernizing Your Incident Management Stack

The on-call platform market in 2025 is at a turning point. While PagerDuty remains a major player in alerting, its model is being challenged by modern, all-in-one platforms. The retirement of Opsgenie further accelerates the need for teams to adopt future-proof solutions.

Rootly provides a more holistic command center for the entire incident lifecycle, from on-call scheduling to automated response and post-incident learning. For teams seeking to modernize their stack, reduce tool sprawl, or migrate from an end-of-life product, Rootly is the clear choice for a resilient and efficient incident management platform.

Ready to see the modern command center in action? Book a demo or start your free trial today.

‍