Best On-Call Software for Teams That Eliminates Alert Fatigue

Alert fatigue is a significant problem for on-call engineering and Site Reliability Engineering (SRE) teams. It's a state of desensitization to alerts caused by an overwhelming number of notifications, many of which are false positives or non-actionable [5]. While on-call software is designed to help, many traditional tools can worsen the problem by simply forwarding every alert. This constant barrage can lead teams to overlook critical alerts due to their sheer frequency [3]. The best oncall software for teams uses intelligent features like automation and alert consolidation to reduce noise and prevent burnout. This article reviews the top on-call management platforms that excel at eliminating alert fatigue and improving incident response.

What is Alert Fatigue and Why is it Crippling On-Call Teams?

Alert fatigue is a state of mental exhaustion caused by excessive, low-priority, or redundant alerts, a common issue for high-velocity teams [4]. The consequences are severe and can ripple across an entire organization:

• Missed critical alerts: This can lead to major service outages and a degraded customer experience.
• Increased Mean Time to Resolution (MTTR): Teams take longer to resolve incidents when they're distracted by noise.
• Engineer burnout and high turnover: Constant, non-actionable pages contribute to stress and can lead to high turnover, particularly among junior analysts [1].
• Operational disruptions and security breaches: Overlooking a critical security alert can leave systems vulnerable to attack [2].

The primary causes of alert fatigue include:

• Alert Overload: Too many monitoring tools send un-triaged notifications directly to responders.
• High Noise-to-Signal Ratio: A large percentage of alerts are not indicative of a real problem. For example, in the tech industry, 52% of alerts are false alarms and 64% are redundant [3].
• Lack of Context: Alerts often lack the information needed to quickly assess their impact or urgency.
• Poorly Defined Escalation: Paging the entire team for every issue, rather than a specific on-call responder, creates unnecessary noise.

Key Features of On-Call Software That Reduce Alert Fatigue

Modern on-call software has evolved beyond simple paging to become a comprehensive incident management platform. The key is to look for features specifically designed to add context, reduce noise, and automate manual tasks.

1. Intelligent Alert Consolidation and Grouping

The best on-call tools automatically group related alerts from various monitoring sources into a single, actionable incident. This de-duplication and bundling prevents responders from being swamped by dozens of notifications for a single underlying issue. Platforms like AlertOps and Squadcast are known for these features, positioning them as strong PagerDuty alternatives by building noise reduction directly into their core product [6].

2. Customizable Workflows and Automation

Automated workflows that take action on an incident without human intervention are crucial for reducing cognitive load. Examples include automatically creating a Slack channel, starting a Zoom meeting, updating a status page, or creating a Jira ticket. This automation frees up responders to focus on investigation and resolution rather than administrative tasks. For instance, you can explore an overview of Rootly to see how workflows can be triggered by incident properties to standardize the entire response process.

3. Flexible On-Call Scheduling and Escalation Policies

Sophisticated scheduling allows for complex rotations, temporary overrides, and region-specific teams, ensuring the right person is always on call. Furthermore, multi-level escalation policies guarantee an alert is never missed. If the primary responder doesn't acknowledge an alert, it automatically escalates to the secondary responder and then to team leadership. This creates clear accountability and reduces the need to page an entire team for every issue.

4. Actionable Analytics and Post-Incident Learning

Robust analytics help teams identify the sources of alert noise. Dashboards can reveal which services or specific alerts are firing most frequently, providing the data needed to tune monitoring systems and reduce false positives. This data is also crucial for post-incident learning. Platforms that provide deep analytics and support for retrospectives make it easier for teams to analyze incidents, understand root causes, and implement preventative measures.

The Best On-Call Software & PagerDuty Alternatives of 2025

This section compares the top platforms, highlighting their strengths in combating alert fatigue. For many organizations, the search for the best incident management platform has become a search for the best PagerDuty alternatives. For a more detailed breakdown, you can review an incident management platform showdown that compares the leading tools.

1. Rootly

Rootly is a comprehensive incident management platform purpose-built for teams that want to automate their response and eliminate toil. It stands out by directly addressing the root causes of alert fatigue.

• Workflow Automation: Rootly’s powerful workflow engine can trigger hundreds of actions based on incident properties like severity or customer impact, automating the entire incident lifecycle.
• Deep Slack Integration: Teams can manage the entire incident from within Slack, centralizing communication and reducing context switching.
• Automated Retrospectives: Rootly automatically gathers incident data, timelines, and action items to generate a complete retrospective, streamlining post-incident learning.
• Customizable Incident Properties: Teams can add rich context to incidents with custom fields, making them easier to triage, route, and analyze.

Rootly is ideal for engineering organizations focused on building a mature reliability strategy and want an integrated platform to manage incidents, improve reliability, and empower their developers.

2. PagerDuty

PagerDuty is a widely adopted and long-standing leader in the on-call management space. Its strengths lie in real-time response orchestration and a vast ecosystem of integrations. However, a common criticism is its complex and expensive pricing model. Many essential features are only available on higher-tier plans or as paid add-ons, and without careful configuration, it can still contribute to alert fatigue [8].

3. Opsgenie (by Atlassian)

Opsgenie is a strong contender, particularly for teams already invested in the Atlassian ecosystem (Jira, Confluence). It is known for its robust alerting and highly flexible on-call scheduling features. Opsgenie is a great choice for teams that require complex scheduling rotations and granular escalation policies to route alerts effectively across a large organization.

4. Squadcast

Squadcast is a modern PagerDuty alternative designed around SRE principles. It emphasizes a highly configurable rule-based automation engine and contextual alert routing to reduce noise [7]. Squadcast also positions itself as a more cost-effective solution compared to PagerDuty, appealing to teams looking for a better value proposition.

How to Choose the Right On-Call Software for Your Team

The "best" tool ultimately depends on your team's specific needs, size, and existing processes. Use this framework to guide your evaluation.

• Assess your primary pain points: Are you drowning in alerts, struggling with communication during incidents, or failing to learn from past failures?
• Evaluate integration needs: Ensure the platform connects seamlessly with your core operational tools, including monitoring (Datadog, Prometheus), chat (Slack, MS Teams), and ticketing (Jira, ServiceNow).
• Prioritize automation and noise reduction: How effectively does the tool group related alerts, automate administrative tasks, and allow for custom routing rules to get the right alert to the right person?
• Analyze scalability and pricing: Will the pricing model scale predictably as your team and services grow? Be wary of complex pricing with hidden fees or expensive add-ons for essential features [6].

Conclusion: Move From Reactive Alerting to Proactive Incident Management

Eliminating alert fatigue isn't about finding a better pager; it's about adopting a smarter incident management strategy. The best on-call software for teams provides automation to handle toil, context to enable quick decision-making, and learning tools to prevent future incidents. This holistic approach reduces noise and empowers engineers to focus on what matters most: building and maintaining reliable systems.

Platforms like Rootly are at the forefront of this shift, offering an integrated solution that covers the entire incident lifecycle. By re-evaluating your current tools, you can build a more resilient engineering culture.

For a deeper comparison of the tools available, explore this Incident Management Platform Showdown: Top 10 Tools Compared.

‍