Best On‑Call Software for Teams: Rootly vs Competitors

In modern IT and engineering, on-call software is critical for maintaining system reliability and minimizing the impact of downtime. The right platform ensures that when an incident occurs, the right people are notified instantly and have the tools they need to resolve it quickly. The market for these tools is dynamic, and with platforms like Opsgenie being sunsetted, many teams are looking for powerful Opsgenie alternatives.

This article provides an in-depth incident management platform comparison, helping your team choose the best fit from the top incident management tools. We will explore what makes the best oncall software for teams, comparing Rootly against established competitors like PagerDuty and outlining a clear migration path for current Opsgenie users.

What to Look for in the Best On-Call Software

Selecting the right on-call software requires evaluating several key features that contribute to a streamlined incident response process. Choosing the right tool involves more than just alerts; it's about empowering your team with a platform that supports them from detection to resolution. Key features to look for include AI capabilities for enhancing operational efficiency, centralized tracking, and workflow automation [8].

Core Features and Capabilities

• On-Call Scheduling & Rotations: The foundation of any on-call system is the ability to create, manage, and override complex schedules and escalation policies to ensure coverage.
• Alerting and Notifications: Your tool must provide reliable, multi-channel alerting via SMS, push notifications, phone calls, and email to ensure responders are notified promptly.
• Incident Lifecycle Management: A centralized platform is essential for managing incidents from the moment they're declared through resolution and the post-mortem phase. Rootly provides a comprehensive overview of the entire incident lifecycle in a single interface.
• Automation & Workflows: The ability to automate repetitive tasks is a game-changer. Look for tools that can automatically create communication channels, page responders, and update stakeholders.
• Integrations: Seamless connections with your existing tech stack—including observability tools, ticketing systems, and communication platforms like Slack—are non-negotiable for an efficient workflow [3].

Collaboration and Usability

During a high-stress incident, a user-friendly interface is crucial for reducing cognitive load. The best on-call software facilitates real-time collaboration, often through a native Slack or Microsoft Teams experience. These tools should act as a central hub for all communication and status updates, ensuring everyone is on the same page without needing to switch between multiple applications [5].

Incident Management Platform Comparison: Rootly vs. Competitors

To help you decide, let's compare some of the top incident management tools on the market.

Rootly: The All-in-One Incident Management Platform

Rootly is a modern, comprehensive solution that unifies on-call scheduling with end-to-end incident management, making it a standout choice for teams aiming to streamline their entire response process.

• Key Strengths:
  • Powerful workflow automation engine that eliminates manual, repetitive tasks.
  • Integrated on-call scheduling, escalations, and alerting.
  • Deep, native Slack integration for managing incidents where your team already works.
  • Automated post-incident analysis, retrospectives, and metrics tracking.
• Best For: Teams seeking a single, centralized platform to manage the entire incident lifecycle, replacing the need for multiple disparate tools.

Rootly is consistently recognized as a leading tool for its all-in-one capabilities, offering a cohesive platform for monitoring, status pages, and on-call scheduling [1].

PagerDuty: The On-Call Alerting Leader

PagerDuty is a well-established leader in the on-call space, renowned for its powerful and reliable alerting and on-call management features.

• Key Strengths:
  • Robust and reliable alerting across numerous channels.
  • An extensive library of over 600 integrations with monitoring and other IT tools [2].
  • Strong focus on digital operations management for enterprise teams.
• Comparison with Rootly: While PagerDuty excels at alerting, Rootly provides a more complete and centralized incident management platform. For teams looking for a holistic solution, Rootly can serve as a wholesale replacement that goes beyond just notifications to manage the entire incident response process.

Opsgenie Alternatives: Migrating Before End-of-Life

Atlassian has announced the end-of-life for Opsgenie, creating an urgent need for its users to find a new solution. This makes the search for Opsgenie alternatives a top priority for many organizations.

• Why Migrate to Rootly: Rootly is the ideal migration path for teams moving off Opsgenie. It offers a more modern and comprehensive feature set, including advanced workflow automation and a native Slack experience that Opsgenie lacks. Rootly provides a seamless transition, ensuring your team can upgrade to a more powerful platform without disrupting your on-call operations.

Feature Comparison Table

This table provides a quick, visual comparison of the key platforms discussed.

Feature

Rootly

PagerDuty

Opsgenie

All-in-One Platform

✅

❌

❌

Integrated On-Call Scheduling

✅

✅

✅

Advanced Workflow Automation

✅

Limited

Limited

Native Slack Experience

✅

Limited

Limited

Automated Retrospectives

✅

Add-on

Limited

Current Status

Active & Growing

Active

End-of-Life

Why Rootly is the Best On-Call Software for Teams

Rootly stands apart from the competition by focusing on unifying and automating the entire incident response process.

Unify Your Entire Incident Response in One Place

Rootly consolidates on-call scheduling, alerting, communication, and post-incident learning into a single, cohesive platform. This approach eliminates tool sprawl and reduces the cognitive load on responders, freeing them up to focus on what matters most: resolution. By managing the complete incident process in one place, teams can work more efficiently and effectively.

Automate Everything to Reduce Toil and MTTR

Rootly's powerful workflow engine is a key differentiator. You can configure it to automatically page the on-call engineer, create a dedicated Slack channel, pull in observability dashboards, and assign incident roles—all without manual intervention. This level of automation significantly speeds up Mean Time to Resolution (MTTR) and eliminates the manual, error-prone work that slows teams down during a crisis.

A Seamless Replacement for PagerDuty and Opsgenie

Rootly is designed to be a superior alternative to traditional on-call tools. It can serve as a full replacement for PagerDuty, offering more comprehensive incident management capabilities beyond just alerting. For teams facing the Opsgenie shutdown, Rootly provides a clear and easy migration path, allowing you to transition to a more powerful, future-proof platform without disruption.

Conclusion: Make the Right Choice for Modern Incident Management

While traditional tools like PagerDuty and Opsgenie have focused heavily on alerting, modern incident management demands a more holistic and automated approach. In this incident management platform comparison, Rootly stands out as the best oncall software for teams by providing a single, powerful platform that covers the entire incident lifecycle—from on-call scheduling and alerting to automated workflows and post-incident learning.

Ready to transform your incident response? Book a demo with Rootly today.

‍